Foreclosure: What families really pay

We all know what the F word means...it means someone is losing their home. A family that has a foreclosure loses what is usually their largest financial asset, but what happens after that? I want to take a minute to explore the real impact of foreclosures on families.

1: First things first. Any equity in the home is lost. Depending on how long they have been in the home this may or may not be that big of a deal. For some, like the family from the Washington Post article a couple of blogs back, it was to the tune of $300,000 . It is hard enough for me to imaging having that kind of money, let alone losing it ;).

2: Deficiency. Whether the home is sold in a short sale, returned via a deed in lieu, or foreclosed upon a lender can seek a deficiency judgment against the borrower for losses. If you owed $200,000 on the mortgage and the lender can only sell it for $150,000 they can come after the original borrower for the difference by taking them to court. The lender will add those pesky court fees to this amount (as they should)as well. Once a deficiency judgment is in place the borrower may find their future wages garnished, liens placed against other property, and may even have financial assets seized. Sometimes the lender won't come after you to pay the money, that sounds good, right? Well, except for the fact they will tell the IRS the money was forgiven.....which means the family has to claim it on their taxes as income! With deficiencies in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in some areas you can imagine what that could do to a tax return......Maybe you could cover it with you $7,500 tax "credit" :) A family who cant pay may turn to....

3. Bankruptcy. Bankruptcy and foreclosure often go hand in hand. The loss of the home may have been precipitated by the loss of a job or major medical problem that will take time to resolve. Just because the home goes away doesn't mean these other problem do as well. Often families in trouble are missing payments on credit cars, cars, student loans, and other obligations as well. Throw a deficiency judgment or increased taxes on top and the elaborate mess is complete. While this may be good news to some, it certainly isn't for the families.

4. Finding a new "home". If you don't have the money to pay your mortgage, how much are you going to have to pay the deposit on your new apartment? Will a change in where you live affect basic expenses, such as travel to work, school, and to purchase goods? Will your children need to change schools? Will the time taken to secure housing impact work schedules while they try to move? How will family and friends be impacted if they crash with them until they get back on their feet or procure new housing? What kind of choices for housing will they have when they now have bad.....

5. Credit. Potential landlords can, and do, check your credit history. When they see a family just lost their home what kind of message does that send to the landlord about their capacity to make payments? For many families that mean they may not be able to obtain reputable housing, accepting landlords who are less scrupulous because they cannot find a place anywhere else. They are unlikely to report bad landlords if they feel that is their only housing option.

Our credit problems don't stop with housing though. Families with poor credit pay more for everything, from credit cards to vehicle loans and even insurance rates. With the family already down on their luck the last thing they want to see is higher insurance rates for their car and credit card rates jump to 29%, yet that is exactly what happens. If they have problems with an overdraft account or auto loan they may find difficulty using that bank again in the future. A family may not even be able to secure a checking account, requiring them to use check cashing services that come with a price.

6. Hard to measure impacts. Money is the easy problem to track. What about lost time? How can depression and stress from financial situations impact parents at work or children at school? Foreclosures are linked to higher levels of deviant behavior including domestic abuse, drinking, suicide, and risk taking behaviors like gambling. While we are busy bailing out banks who will foot the bill, or even more importantly provide the counseling/supports for families after they lose their homes? (Not every one lost it because they overextended their credit or obtained a stupid loan). High density foreclosure areas often have higher levels of crime and unoccupied buildings can serve as safe havens for illegal activities and contribute to neighborhood/price decline. Yet with our economy struggling social service agencies and police departments who need extra help to cope are finding their budgets cut instead.

The real irony here is this does not even look at the impact it has on banks, investors, and neighborhoods as a whole. The cost is truly staggering.

The foreclosure is a hard pill to swallow, but its the after taste that has me worried.

So where do we go from here? Like it or not, keeping families in their home is usually the best option. That means we need loan servicers, and more importantly the investors they represent, to be willing to work with borrowers who can reasonably afford to pay for their homes. This may require some kind of loan modification to ensure the solution is a long term one.

Perhaps its time we supported building smaller homes? If the homes were smaller, and more affordable in the first place, would we still have this problem?

We need to look for supports to families who need assistance procuring safe affordable housing and dealing with stresses on the family stemming from the foreclosures. We need more money headed towards social services, not tax breaks for race track owners and rum exports from Puerto Rico. Perhaps the main thing that needs to be cut from government spending is the paychecks and benefits of lawmakers who waste our time and money.